50 Years Ago Today: The New York Times Calls Elton John ‘Wallpaper Music’
The review from his record-breaking, seven-night stand at Madison Square Garden enraged Elton. "It was the most piss elegant review I’ve ever seen," he told Rolling Stone later that year
The New York Times' scathing review of Elton John's concerts at Madison Square Garden 50 years ago today is a fascinating footnote in music history. Dubbing his music "wallpaper music" was a dismissive blow, especially given the record-breaking, seven-night stand that was supposed to cement his status as a rock star. The review's condescending tone, which Elton John himself described as "piss elegant," suggests that the critic saw John's music as bland, unremarkable, and only fit for background listening.
This review matters because it highlights the lingering perception of Elton John as a pop artist rather than a serious rock musician. At the time, John was transitioning from being a critically acclaimed singer-songwriter to a more commercial, arena-ready act. The Times' review reflects a bias that many rock fans and critics held against Elton John: that he was more concerned with showmanship and hits than with artistic depth or musical innovation. However, this criticism also underscores Elton John's remarkable ability to endure and thrive despite such dismissive assessments.
As we look ahead, it's worth watching how Elton John's legacy continues to evolve. With his recent biopic, Rocketman, and ongoing performances, John remains a beloved and respected figure in music. His ability to adapt and reinvent himself over the decades has allowed him to transcend the criticisms of his past and maintain a devoted fan base. As the music industry continues to grapple with issues of artistic credibility and commercial success, Elton John's story serves as a reminder that an artist's worth can't be reduced to a single review or perception – and that sometimes, it's the most enduring acts that are also the most misunderstood.
Originally reported by rollingstone.com. MusicNewsletter adds analysis for culture, style & media readers.